Plantation Shutters vs. Blinds: Which Is Right for Your Florida Home?

The short comparison

• Plantation shutters: permanent, cordless, very durable, wipe clean, higher cost up front
• Blinds: lower cost, easy to change later, more slat and finish choices, cordless or corded
• Both: control light and privacy by tilting, and both can be made to measure

When plantation shutters are the better choice

Shutters are built like furniture and fixed to the window frame. There is nothing to fray, and very little to break. They suit rooms with hard daily use, strong sun and windows you want to look built in, including French doors, sliders, arches and street-facing windows.

They are also a popular choice when a home is being prepared for sale, because they stay with the house.

When blinds are the better choice

Blinds cost less, which matters on a whole-house project. They are easier to change later if your style changes, and they come in a wide range of finishes. Faux wood blinds handle humidity well, so they suit kitchens, bathrooms and laundry rooms. Real wood blinds are lighter and suit wide windows in air-conditioned rooms.

Using both in one house

Many homeowners use plantation shutters on the main living areas and street-facing windows, and faux wood blinds or shades on secondary windows and bedrooms. It keeps the look consistent where people see it, and it keeps the budget in check.

Safety and care

Shutters have no cords at all. Blinds are available cordless, which is the safer choice for homes with children and pets. Shutters wipe clean with a damp cloth or a duster. Faux wood blinds wipe clean too.

See both at your windows

We bring samples of both to your home, measure every window and give you one written quote. That lets you compare them in your own light and see exactly what each would cost.

Products mentioned in this guide

• Plantation Shutters
  Timeless, durable and easy to clean. A permanent upgrade to the house.
• Faux Wood Blinds
  The look of painted wood slats in a material that shrugs off moisture.
• Wood Blinds
  Real wood slats with natural grain and precise control over light.
• Cordless Roller Shades
  Simple and modern. Lift by hand, with no cords or chains.

Common questions